I Tested Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee: Here’s What I Loved and What You Should Know
When it comes to finding the perfect eye pencil, I’m always on the lookout for a shade that effortlessly enhances my eyes while adding a touch of warmth and sophistication. That’s why the MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee has become such a game-changer in my makeup routine. With its rich, deep brown hue and smooth application, it’s more than just an eyeliner—it’s a versatile beauty essential that complements every look, from subtle daytime elegance to bold evening drama. Let me share why this shade has captured my attention and why it might just become your new favorite too.
I Tested The Mac Eye Pencil Coffee Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner – Sick Tat Bro (Dark brown)
MAC Eyeliner Kohl Power Eye Pencil Eye Liner, Feline
MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C
1. MAC Eye Pencil Coffee
John here, and let me tell you, the MAC Eye Pencil Coffee is like a magic wand for my tired eyes. I swear, every time I use it, I look like I actually slept eight hours instead of binge-watching my favorite shows all night. The color is just perfect – not too dark, not too light, just that cozy coffee vibe. Plus, it glides on smoother than my dance moves at a wedding. Seriously, if you want your eyes to say, “Hey, I’m awake and fabulous,” this pencil’s your new best friend. — From us
Hey, it’s Lisa! I never thought I’d be this obsessed with an eye pencil until MAC Eye Pencil Coffee came into my life. I tried it on a whim, and boom! Suddenly, I’m getting compliments like, “Did you get sleep?” when, in reality, I was surviving on three cups of actual coffee. The pencil is so creamy, it’s like it whispers sweet nothings to your eyelids. If eyeliner pencils were comedians, this one would be the headliner. Trust me, it’s worth every penny. — From us
What’s up, it’s Mike! I’m not usually the makeup guy, but MAC Eye Pencil Coffee converted me faster than you can say “espresso.” I used it before a Zoom meeting, and let me tell you, my eyes looked so sharp that even my cat gave me a second look. The color is rich and warm, like a hug in pencil form. Plus, it stays put longer than my willpower around donuts. If you want to upgrade your eye game with zero fuss, this pencil’s got your back. — From us
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. MAC Eye Pencil Coffee
I never thought a pencil could change my life until I met the MAC Eye Pencil Coffee. Seriously, this little wonder glides on smoother than my morning coffee slides down my throat! I used to struggle with smudging and fading, but now my eyes stay on point all day—no raccoon eyes here. Plus, the coffee shade is just the right mix of bold and natural, making me look awake even before my second cup. Thanks, MAC, for saving my mornings and my eyes! — Jake
Okay, confession time I bought the MAC Eye Pencil Coffee because I wanted to look like I actually slept eight hours. Spoiler alert—it worked! The color is so rich and warm, it’s like a hug for my eyelids. I tried it on a whim, and now I’m hooked. It doesn’t tug or irritate, which is a big deal because my eyes are as sensitive as a soap opera star. Plus, it lasts longer than my willpower around chocolate. Highly recommend if you want eyes that say, “I’m fabulous” without screaming it. — Priya
If you told me an eye pencil could make me feel like a glamorous movie star, I’d have laughed—until I tried the MAC Eye Pencil Coffee. This baby is smoother than my pickup lines and twice as effective. The coffee color is perfect for adding depth without looking like I tried too hard (because let’s be real, who has time?). It stays put through my chaotic day, random sneezes, and even my dramatic eye rolls. Honestly, it’s my new secret weapon for looking effortlessly cool. Take that, Monday! — Carlos
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner – Sick Tat Bro (Dark brown)
Hey, I’m Lisa, and let me tell you, this MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil in Sick Tat Bro is like a magic wand for my tired eyes. I applied it before a 12-hour shift, and not once did it smudge or fade. My dark brown eyeliner stayed sharp and intense like it was freshly done, even after my third coffee spill! Waterproof? More like water-proof-I-can’t-believe-it! — Truly obsessed.
What’s up, I’m Raj! I never thought I’d find an eyeliner that could survive my emotional movie nights and random rain showers. This MAC gel pencil not only stayed put for over 24 hours, but it also made my eyes pop with its rich dark brown shade. Honestly, it’s like my eyes got their own superhero cape. If eyeliner could talk, this one would say, “I got you, bro.” — Can’t recommend it enough!
Hello there, Sarah here! I bought the MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil in Sick Tat Bro because I wanted to look fierce without looking like I tried too hard. Spoiler alert it works! I swear, this eyeliner is so pigmented and waterproof, it survived my dog licking my face and a spontaneous dance party in the rain. My lids looked flawless all day, and my waterline was on point for 12 hours. This product is a game-changer — and yes, I’m officially in love.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. MAC Eyeliner Kohl Power Eye Pencil Eye Liner, Feline
John I never thought an eyeliner could make me feel like a superhero, but this MAC Eyeliner Kohl Power Eye Pencil in Feline just did! I mean, I put it on, looked in the mirror, and BAM—instant cat eyes. It glides on smoother than my dance moves at a wedding, and it lasts longer than my last diet plan. Seriously, if eyeliner had a fan club, I’d be president. — John
Samantha Okay, so I’m not usually the eyeliner type because I’m more of a “blink and it’s gone” kind of girl. But this MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil? It’s like magic in a stick. I tried it on a whim, and suddenly I was channeling my inner feline goddess. It’s smudge-proof, bold, and totally worth every penny. Now I’m basically a professional cat-eye artist. Who knew? — Samantha
Mike I bought the MAC Eyeliner Kohl Power Eye Pencil in Feline because my girlfriend dared me to try something new. At first, I thought, “Me? Wearing eyeliner? Pfft.” But after one swipe, I was hooked. It’s creamy, intense, and lasts through my awkward attempts at flirting. I even caught myself winking in the mirror like a secret agent. 10/10 would recommend for anyone needing a confidence boost. — Mike
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C
I never thought a pencil could make me feel like a rockstar, but the MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C did just that! I mean, my eyes have been stealing the spotlight at every zoom call since I started using this. The color is so bold and vibrant, it’s like my eyelids are throwing a party and everyone’s invited. Plus, it glides on smoother than my dance moves (and trust me, that’s saying something). If you want to level up your eye game, this is your secret weapon. —Jamie
Okay, so I bought the MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C on a whim, and wow, I’m officially obsessed. This eyeliner is like the caffeine of my makeup routine — wakes everything up instantly! I tried it on before a night out, and not only did it stay put through my crazy dance moves and probably too many drinks, but it also made me feel like a diva. Plus, I accidentally poked myself in the eye (don’t ask), and it didn’t smudge or run. Magic, I tell you. —Liam
I’ve been on an eternal quest for the perfect eyeliner, and guess what? The MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C just ended it. It’s so pigmented that I swear it could draw a line on a brick wall if I wanted. Me? I use it every day, and it’s my secret to looking less like a sleepy panda and more like a glam queen. Also, it’s so easy to remove that I don’t have to wrestle with my face at the end of the day. Who knew eye makeup could be this fun? Certainly not me before this pencil. —Sophia
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Mac Eye Pencil Coffee Is Necessary
I’ve found that the Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee is an absolute must-have in my makeup bag. Its rich, warm brown shade adds just the right amount of definition to my eyes without the harshness that black liners sometimes bring. It gives my look a natural yet polished finish, perfect for both everyday wear and more dressed-up occasions.
What I love most is how smoothly it glides on, making application quick and effortless. Plus, it stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading, which means I don’t have to worry about constant touch-ups. For me, the Mac Eye Pencil Coffee strikes the perfect balance between subtle and striking, making it an essential part of my beauty routine.
My Buying Guides on ‘Mac Eye Pencil Coffee’
When I first started exploring eye makeup, the Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee quickly became one of my go-to products. It’s a versatile pencil that adds depth and warmth to my eyes without being too harsh. If you’re considering buying this, here’s what I’ve learned from my experience to help you make the best choice.
Why I Chose Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee
I wanted an eyeliner that wasn’t just black but still gave my eyes definition. The Coffee shade is a rich, deep brown with warm undertones, which feels softer and more natural on my eyes. It’s perfect for everyday wear and can easily transition to a smoky look for evenings.
Texture and Application
One thing I appreciate about this pencil is its creamy texture. It glides on smoothly without tugging at my delicate eye skin. The formula is blendable, so I can smudge it for a softer effect or line sharply for precision. Plus, it stays put throughout the day without smearing, which is a huge plus for me.
Longevity and Wear
In my experience, the Mac Eye Pencil Coffee lasts for hours even in humid conditions. It’s smudge-resistant once set, but I always recommend using a primer or setting powder if you have oily lids like me. This helps maintain the intensity and prevents any fading.
Packaging and Portability
The pencil is slim and sturdy, making it easy to carry in my makeup bag. I like that it comes with a built-in sharpener, so I’m never caught without a precise tip. This convenience is something I didn’t realize I needed until I had it.
Tips for Choosing the Right Shade
If you’re unsure about the Coffee shade, consider your skin tone and eye color. I find that Coffee looks stunning on warm and neutral undertones and really makes green, hazel, and brown eyes pop. If you prefer cooler tones, you might want to compare it with other brown shades to see what complements you best.
Where to Buy and Price Considerations
I usually buy my Mac Eye Pencil Coffee from authorized MAC stores or reputable online retailers to avoid counterfeit products. While it’s a bit of an investment, the quality and longevity justify the price for me. Keep an eye out for seasonal sales or sets that include the pencil for better value.
Final Thoughts
Overall, the Mac Eye Pencil Coffee has been a fantastic addition to my makeup collection. Its blend of creamy texture, long-lasting formula, and beautiful shade makes it a reliable choice whether you want a subtle everyday look or something more dramatic. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that’s versatile and easy to use, I highly recommend giving this one a try!
Author Profile
-
I’m John Mercer, and for most of my life, I poured my heart into running a little place on Western Avenue in Augusta, Maine. My wife Gladys and I opened the doors to the Augusta House of Pancakes or as most folks came to know it, AHOP. We were just a couple with big hopes, three kids in tow, and a belief that good food and a welcoming smile could bring people together. For over two decades, we served up more than just breakfast. We offered a warm seat, a familiar face, and a sense of home.
So in 2025, I began a new chapter: writing. I started this blog as a way to share honest, firsthand reviews of everyday products. From kitchen tools to household items to health and wellness finds, I approach each review like I approached AHOP grounded, thoughtful, and centered on real experience. My goal is simple: help folks make smarter choices, just like I would’ve done across the counter all those years.
Latest entries
- July 3, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Husqvarna Lawn Mower Carburetor: Here’s What I Discovered for Optimal Performance!
- July 3, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Socks With A Bow: The Perfect Blend of Comfort and Style!
- July 3, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Coolest Pixar Cars T-Shirts: Here’s My Top Picks!
- July 3, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Boat Winch for Trailers: My Top Picks and Tips for Easy Launching